‘surprise’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
surprise 

Category

Evil Bondage Sister Ch. 03

Red's little sister is caught in Red's trap.

NEWH
4.61
3.9k
4
0
6

Kaitlyn's April Fools' Joke

She was forced to make a horrible AF joke.

NEWH
4.7
12.7k
22
23
50
0

Amy's Night Away

While out of town, a mom has a one night stand.

NEWH
4.52
20.2k
30
25
62
0

Table Turning Shauna on Tinder

Shauna's Tinder date takes an unexpected turn.

NEW
3.78
5.1k
4
0
8
0

Nurse Paula Pt. 03

Vince gets a text, from Paula?

4.39
3.3k
2
0
6

Full of Surprises! Pt. 02

The mystery woman returns.

H
4.77
1.5k
6
0
9

Mary's Surprise Night Out

John and Mary return to a night of fun.

4.28
3.5k
8
3
17
0

Lila the Lady of Laughter

A vivacious blond takes the village by storm on April Fool's.

4.18
5.9k
8
1
14
0

Full of Surprises!

My wife doesn't usually like cunnilingus, but surprises me!

4.43
5.5k
5
4
15

Tricked into Trying New Things

A friend's sister tricks me into trying new things.

4.24
20.3k
15
3
31
0

Masquerade - A Revenge Story

A sex party that turns into a revenge mission.

4.16
5.4k
9
1
16
0

A Short Story - Blue Surprise

Blue surprise leads to eating arse.

0
1.2k
0
2
4
0

Claire First Experiences Rough Sex

claire's first time having sex forced on her.

3.74
10.1k
7
3
13
0

Not On The List (In 750 Words)

A Husband Discovers He Didn't Make The List.

4.45
34.3k
73
119
127
0

Her Turn . . . Again? (750 Words)

Can she convince him that three can be a good number?

3.96
17.9k
25
73
52

Sweet Suitemate Seduction

Not your typical porno massage seduction.

H
4.83
14.6k
27
16
52
0

Bill, We Need to Talk - 750 Words

She tells her husband of her important decision.

4.33
12.6k
19
48
41
0

Bribing the Roommates Ch. 03

Natalie and her boyfriend get busted.

4.37
5.4k
8
5
14

Operation "Groomer"

Husband Surprises Wife with a Grooming.

0
2.4k
5
0
7
0

Unexpected Company Pt. 01-03

College dorm friends accidentally catch a couple in bed.

4.48
4.3k
3
0
16
0

Smut Review - The Hotel (5.34)

Retelling of a MMF story that made me cum. Twice.

H
4.62
3.5k
2
5
6
0

The Week that Changed My Life

Wife fulfills all husbands secret fantasies during vacation.

H
4.72
20.4k
43
10
92
0

The Surprise Storm

A Storm came out of nowhere for Kaylee. so did someone else.

3.67
3.6k
2
2
7
0

Candy Hearts - 750 Words

Who was leaving him messages of love?

H
4.61
5.6k
7
25
28
0

Holly's Secret

Can you ever truly outrun your past?

H
4.76
14.3k
32
29
72
0

Lightning Pt. 02

Matt has just come face to face with Olde Trip Girl.

4.46
2.2k
6
9
12

My Valentine Dilemma

I never thought she had it in her.

3.89
41.9k
29
66
72
0

Sisters in Law Pt. 01

First time with Cat and Alice.

H
4.61
19.4k
21
3
62

The Captain Rum Sodomy & the Lash

A relaxing cruise gets kinky as Captain eyes you.

4.26
4.1k
2
2
8
0

Twin Paradox

Faith and Hope can feel everything the other twin feels.

H
4.64
21.4k
41
8
88
0

Bribing the Roommates Ch. 02

Mike’s roommates demand more from Natalie.

4.42
13.2k
23
2
34

Learning About AI

You believe what you earnestly want to believe.

4.02
19.1k
30
43
70
0

Exploration While She Sleeps

Two people find passion during the night.

4.08
10.1k
2
0
10
0

Bribing the Roommates Ch. 01

Natalie's bribery scheme goes awry.

H
4.74
18.8k
42
2
93

The Dream Pt. 01

Dream of seeing my brother again... Leading up to the spicy.

3.9
10.1k
15
4
35

Casual First Night Encounter

Surprise Times Square ball drop hookup.

H
4.53
9.4k
12
8
25
0

A Redheaded Tomboy and Gucci Girl

Force-feeding my body with sensory pleasures of disbelief.

4.12
10.7k
10
4
22
0

Surprise First-Time Threesome

Jan gets woken up to her man and one more.

2.56
13.8k
9
0
21
0

Cuck with Wife and Three Guys

Cuck Surprises Wife with 3-Man Sandwich.

4.13
10.7k
13
2
28
0

The Tale of Mpreg Pinocchio Pt. 02

His wife returns and is surprised by his pregnant belly.

3.67
1.8k
5
0
6

The Tale of Mpreg Pinocchio Pt. 01

He pretended to be pregnant, and it became real.

4.29
3.1k
5
0
10

Jeff Greegan's First Time

The ultimate birthday present makes him a man.

4.24
19.5k
21
4
45
0

An End of Term Party

Opening a window at a party can end with a lovely surprise.

H
4.73
9.2k
9
1
26
0

Helen Gets a Visitor

Helen is surprised when her lover turns up.

2.39
18.9k
13
6
26

No You Don't, in 750 Words

He didn't respond the way she expected.

4.32
54.9k
82
118
150
0

I Wanna Mommy fo' Chwismus

A most heartbreaking request to Santa.

H
4.87
19.9k
82
55
140
0

Night Surprise

Middle of the night tryst, with a nice surprise.

4.03
6.4k
2
2
4
0

Brother in-law Get His Way Pt. 01

Brother in-law took me by surprise and I loved it.

4.28
46.5k
57
10
104

Rachaels Birthday Stranger

Rachael is surprised as a mystery man joins their lovemaking.

3.86
8.7k
15
3
28
0

Daddy's Girls Ch. 01

Lovely daughter has a surprise for Daddy.

4.43
56.4k
90
15
187

The Thralls of the Wyvern's Bane Ch. 03

Oliver and Jia attend Chris and Julie's wedding.

H
4.71
4k
3
2
11

Her Secret Desire

Sarah bored of her sex life so she surprises her husband.

H
4.61
30.3k
27
11
61
0

Five Mums Ch. 38 - Half Round of Golf

A game of golf, greens, dirt bunkers included everyone wins.

H
4.72
6.6k
7
2
13

Maid Just For You

She surprises her boyfriend on his birthday.

4.36
8.4k
8
2
21
0

Maggie's Night Out

Maggie surprises a dentist at his office.

H
4.61
7.6k
5
0
10
0

Dogwalkers

I was just walking my dog, and so was she.

H
4.71
7.3k
8
0
17
0

Wife and Her Online Master (M4F)

Wife secretly becomes a sub to a stranger.

4.08
5.3k
6
1
12
0

Going Away Surprise

Gangbanged at Ray's going away surprise party.

4.44
13.8k
13
0
34
0

The Lone Ranger and the Ho

Our intrepid hero rescues a woman of ill repute.

H
4.8
10.8k
15
11
38
0

I Hate Miles Bonn

So why did I fuck him on Halloween?

H
4.66
8.8k
14
15
40
0

Hot Tub Mixup

A stranger helps husband get closer to his wife.

3.74
28.6k
20
17
48
0

Five Mums Ch. 34 - Date Night

Our 'First date" and jay surprises himself.

H
4.75
2.3k
3
5
4

A Small Bottle of Milk

Suddenly, a shock one summer evening in a convenience store.

H
4.67
4.8k
9
3
13
0

My Sissy College Experience Pt. 01

I move into my dorm, and my roommate is perfect, or is he?

4.38
17.3k
21
3
36

The Ladies Pull It Off

Four ladies surprise their men.

H
4.77
19.8k
31
10
80
0

Samantha Snaps Her Fingers Pt. 05

Samantha’s assistant lets the new intern know her secret.

4.56
1.7k
00
1

The Spur Ch. 16

New Year's Eve Bellydance Party.

4.8
871
00
3

Shoreline Secrets

Beach hangout turned epic with surprise sex!

3.39
3.2k
0
2
00

Morning Wood

Sexy surprise for roommate's boyfriend.

4.49
25k
23
3
39
0

I Miss My Wife

A man misses his wife.

3.42
30.7k
22
61
64
0

Work From Home Pt. 01

Husband gives wife a surprise while she works from home.

3.18
20k
13
21
25

Mistakes, and Consequences

Visiting a friend, led to a sudden thrilling sex experience.

4.33
17.9k
18
6
34
0

Kitchen Submission

Raiding the fridge has never been so hot!

H
4.68
10.4k
14
4
35
0

The Sunbather Ch. 05

Caught by surprise cruising at night.

4.38
2.7k
1
1
2

Fishnets / French Maid Ch. 02

Desiree role plays for Terrance. Dakota gets a surprise.

H
4.7
9k
29
8
42

Car Talk

Before college, mechanic shows love with tools.

H
4.61
5.1k
4
7
13
0

Artist at the Arts Fair

The artist takes his works to an out of town arts fair.

H
4.87
11.8k
23
21
47

CFNM with Neighbour, Aunt & More Ch. 03

My neighbour plays more games on me but I love it.

H
4.69
12.7k
16
8
24

Game Day - Playoffs

The team goes deeper... into the playoffs.

H
4.77
26k
18
4
54

New friend needed to pee Ch. 01

Helping a friend lead to night of discoveries for both of us.

H
4.69
19.9k
35
8
50

Two Step Tango

I said "yes" and now I'm fighting my internal demons.

3.31
2k
1
1
4
0

Tied Up and Pleasured for Art - M4F

She's blindfolded, tied up & pleasured by a dominant artist.

H
4.65
12.6k
9
2
22
0

The Sunbather Ch. 02 - The Stranger 01

Meeting "the stranger" while nude sunbathing...sucking cocks.

4.43
6.5k
4
5
6

I feel ridiculous

Making dinner takes an unexpected turn

3.6
2.9k
2
1
2
0

Surprise Party with Friends

After dinner Mark's wife allowed him an extra birthday gift.

H
4.52
21.4k
22
5
50
0

An Unexpectedly Erotic Date Night

Dinner, a show and new friends lead to more and more fun.

4.45
7.9k
4
3
7
0

Tina Visits - Pt. 05

Part 5 of the Tina visits story - Tina's naughty daughter.

H
4.52
3k
3
0
4

Friends

A couple of friends dropped in to see her.

4.16
18.2k
18
6
36
0

A night of firsts

A weekend birthday getaway, turns into an eye opening serie.

H
4.64
19.3k
13
3
34
0

Friend's Wife - Planning His Party

My friend turned 26, but I got to know his wife better.

3.98
25.7k
23
7
40

100mph Inside, 60mph Outside

A surprise and fun on the road while my wife drove.

3.93
8.8k
7
3
14
0

Something for the Weekend

A barber saves the day; but at a price.

H
4.67
10.7k
16
9
23
0

Makeshift Double

Young lady comes home to her partner's mischievous surprise.

3.38
3.1k
2
0
5
0

Do You Have Any Shorts That Fit

Buying shorts can be exhausting says the 'straight' guy.

H
4.64
11.8k
18
8
33
0

New Thing Ch. 01

Some doors shouldn't be walked through.

3.98
24.4k
35
27
73

Lesbian Surprises at Work Retreat

Surprise lesbian bonding during a women's weekend work event.

H
4.64
21.6k
28
7
47
0
Active tags
Active tags
surprise
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ