Try the free LITEROTICA WEBCAMS!

‘reluctant anal’ stories

Active tags
Active tags
reluctant anal 

Category

Sort by:
ViewsRatingFavoriteNewest
30 DaysAll Time

Perion Ch. 15 Finale

Revenge is a dish best served hard.

by SawyerElle in Novels and Novellas 05/05/2025
H
4.53
0
703
0
1
1

Lisa's Family Tragedy Pt. 02

Helping Lisa in her time of need.

by likesthemlittle in NonConsent/Reluctance 04/03/2024
H
4.58
0
8.5k
8
0
8

How Bad Do You Want It?

Two interns. One position. How far will they go to get it?

by darktigerroar in Anal 07/19/2020
4.42
0
41.1k
20
0
16
0

Still Grinning and Utterly Ruined

"Use your words."

by awkwardguurl in NonConsent/Reluctance 09/25/2018
3.86
0
27.9k
6
2
6
0

Dirty Dozen Ch. 03: Lais Ribeiro

Fucking Lais Ribeiro in a tropical paradise.

by u1u1u1 in Celebrities & Fan Fiction 11/30/2017
4.31
0
11.5k
10
1
2

Taken by Request

Wife's kidnapping fantasy is fulfilled.

by ToddAndLynnExcelAdv in BDSM 08/01/2017
4.33
0
36.3k
22
1
21
0

50's House Wife

Role-playing submissive servicing her man.

by ToddAndLynnExcelAdv in Erotic Couplings 08/05/2016
4.29
0
80.3k
26
1
17
0

Suck My Big Tits Pt. 09

Daddy finally takes my ass, but he doesn't have permission.

by breastysadie in Anal 07/08/2014
4.37
0
210.6k
120
5
48

Pixie Takes it Up The Ass

While pushy mother looks on.

by TheDarkCloud in NonConsent/Reluctance 03/31/2010
3.99
0
255.1k
99
7
36
0

A Moonlit First

He takes her ass for the very first time.

by merelyme in Anal 04/17/2009
4.14
0
117.3k
22
7
7
0

Obsession

She was completely his for the taking.

by ponyfitness in NonConsent/Reluctance 06/14/2008
4.17
0
139.9k
27
3
8
0

Masturbation Interrupted

Pleasuring yourself and "punished" for it.

by Morrigu in Anal 06/03/2007
4.15
0
106.9k
15
8
5
0

Sarah's Games Ch. 05

Really bad girls get fucked in the ass.

by suggestiveness in Anal 04/28/2006
4.47
0
190.6k
38
4
7

Ashlee's Undoing

Blonde's teasing of older neighbour gets out of hand.

by mpqm1968 in NonConsent/Reluctance 07/23/2005
4.26
0
237.4k
38
5
26
0
Active tags
Active tags
reluctant anal
Separate tags with commas. More info in the FAQ